Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie

Sharing is caring!

Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie is a classic, traditional southern pie. It’s simple and made from regular ingredients, but it tastes so good. Buttermilk Pie is creamy, sweet heaven. It’s one of my very favorite pies.

Old-fashioned Buttermilk Pie

 

Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie has a super smooth, custard-like filling that is really sweet. The filling only takes about 5 minutes to make and consists of eggs, buttermilk, sugar, melted butter, flour for thickening, and lemon juice, vanilla extract, and nutmeg for flavor.

Old-fashioned Buttermilk Pie

 

Buttermilk Pie is very similar to Chess Pie only a Chess Pie typically has cornmeal and a Buttermilk Pie does not.

Old-fashioned Buttermilk Pie

 

You can use a store bought pie crust or make your own. Watch the video below to learn how to make an easy homemade Flaky Pie Crust.

You can eat Buttermilk Pie warm, room temperature, or chilled. I think it tastes best straight from the refrigerator, especially when the weather is warm. Then it is cool and creamy and oh so delicious.

Old-fashioned Buttermilk Pie

Old-fashioned Buttermilk Pie

Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie

Old-Fashioned Buttermilk pie is super sweet with a little tang. Such an easy pie to make!
4.73 from 33 votes
Print Pin Rate
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: Southern
Prep Time: 10 minutes
Cook Time: 50 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour
Servings: 8
Author: Christin Mahrlig

Ingredients

  • 3 eggs
  • 1 1/2 cups sugar
  • 1/2 cup butter melted and cooled
  • 3 tablespoons flour
  • 1 cup buttermilk
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1/8 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • pinch of salt
  • 1 9-inch pie crust, unbaked

Instructions

  • In a large bowl, whisk together eggs and sugar.
  • Whisk in remaining ingredients until smooth.
  • Pour into prepared pie crust.
  • Bake at 400 for 10 minutes.
  • Reduce heat to 350 degrees and continue bake for 40 to 45 minutes.

More Pie Recipes

Brownie Pie- tastes like a fudgy brownie in a pie crust!

Brownie Pie

Lemon Chess Pie- an old-fashioned dessert that's super easy to make from basic ingredients.

Lemon Chess Pie

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links.

Let's Keep in Touch

Delicious recipes delivered straight to your inbox!



90 thoughts on “Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie

  1. I love this simple recipe! I made it dairy free by subbing 1 cup oat milk with 1 tbsp lemon for the buttermilk. You can barely tell the difference and it didn’t alter the texture.

      1. I did too!!! I put it out in the garage to cool and forgot about it. Pie was in the oven for 2 min when I remembered, so I poured it back in the mixing bowl and added the butter! 😳 Still in the oven- fingers crossed! 😊

  2. So I stumbled onto this recipe by chance while looking for a costume for my kid. I used a graham cracker crust and followed the cook time to the T- I kept the pie in for only 40mins and I have an electric stove. The pie crust didn’t burn and the consistency of the center was slightly softer than that of the sides. Sort of like a brownie I guess, anyway I placed it in the fridge to cool faster because I really wanted a slice and was very happy with the results and how the pie turned out. When I cut a slice nothing fell apart to include the center and the consistency was all the same. I now love buttermilk pie!

  3. If you’re using a frozen pie shell, does the pie shell have to be pre baked? It’s so ironic I wouldn’t eat Buttermilk Pie as a kid because I hate Buttermilk. I had a slice at Cracker Barrel and now I have to have it!

    1. Me too, I tasted it at cracker Barrels and I’m making two and it’s 12 AM that’s how much I wanted it. I never heard of it until I moved to the South… It’s soooo yummy🤗

  4. had It for the first time at Cracker Barrel came home and found this recipe and loved it!! It’s so easy to make and it came out near perfect. I topped it wait strawberries and whip cream. I think I might try pineapple next. I did add lemon extract and not juice. It went perfect with the strawberries. It was served cold and it went so fast! Thanks for the awesome recipe Christin!!

    1. I had this at Cracker Barrel as well and loved it. I plan on making it today for Mother’s Day. Regarding the very rude comment left below, I will side with you and simply say we shall be “pigs” together. Oink Oink.

  5. I moved to CO two years ago from the Great State of Texas— family rooted from the Carolinas, Southern FL, Atlanta and Louisiana. Never in my life would I imagine living in such a place where no one says thank you when you hold the door, and they’ve never heard of buttermilk or sweet potato pie!!!!!! I make about 2 of these a week, keeps my fiancé happy and my elderly neighbors cholestorol up.

    I ALWAYS bake this at night just before going to bed, right as it’s done cooking, I turn the oven off and crack it and allow the pie to slowly come down to temp in there. Perfect consistency. We eat the slices with our hands as a snack (less dishes!).

    1. Can I please have your recipe as i fail on chess pie, grandson says not enough butter flavor or it bombs. My sweet potato pie is ok but seem to lack the flavor my son-in-law from LA wants, margie

  6. I made this tonight. Used an organic cane sugar. And a graham cracker crust. Cooked just like recipe called for and it was burnt! I’m not sure if it’s the cane sugar? Or the fact the recipe did not specify when you lower the oven temps to take out and wait for it to cool before cooking it the rest? At 30 minutes at 350 it was brown and not cooked in middle. Any suggestions?

  7. I used self rising flour because the recipe didn’t specify plain flour also in the video I didn’t see butter being used but in the recipe it states to use a half cup of melted butter. So st this point I don’t know how the pie is to taste . 🤷🏽‍♀️

    1. I used the butter but I substituted the sugar with stevia. (2 cups). Not sweet enough for me but it tastes really good still. I know it sounds weird but I tried it with pancake syrup… really good.

      1. You might add a bit of honey or another natural sweetener to the stevia. A mix so it doesn’t come out tasting of honey. Best of luck.

  8. I had a recipe book printed by my church to raise money in 1958. The years took it’s toll on my book. Could not find the recipe for the Buttermilk Pie, requested by my family every year. Sat down this morning to Google help. Lucky I found you. Same exact recipe, I am so pleased to find you. Merry Christmas to you and all your readers.

  9. I tried your recipe because my cookbooks were still boxed from our move. I made 3 for our Potluck Thanksgiving at work, the lady’s kept asking me if I was bringing my famous buttermilk pie but I improvised with your recipe. It was awesome t they never knew the difference. Thanks for your help, I think I’m going with yours from now on. Mike in San Antonio, Texas.

  10. I always use lemon extract for this pie. Very traditional in my family. If your in a higher altitude use a tablespoon of cornstarch to avoid runny middles.

    1. Thank goodness I read this!! I was totally out of vanilla extract and used lemon… I feel much better now. It’s in the oven now so we will see if it works for me too!! 🤞🤞🤞

    2. Wish I had read this before I put them in the oven! I have lived here 4 years and am still not used to modifying every blessed recipe ! I haven’t tried the pie yet, but I’ll bet it has a gooey center. Ah, well, next time!

  11. I decided to make it for my training class I was in for the last day and they ate it all….one lady wants me to make one for her birthday in April. I’m adding crushed pineapple and coconut in the next one…

  12. Why does the recipe call for a 1/2 cup of melted butter but the video omits adding the butter?
    I followed the recipe using low-fat buttermilk and the pie came out with a 4 inch round section of what looked like melted butter. I followed the recipe. Any thoughts?
    Thank you

    1. Sometimes it’s the difference in using butter vs margarine. I have always used butter. The one time I used margarine it came out like what your talking about.

    2. Mine came out the same way! I cooled the butter but it wasn’t cold. I used a siring to remove the “pool” of butter. The pie looks beautiful otherwise.

    3. I used butter not margarine and mine came out the same way, I also noticed in the video no butter was used so on my next try I’m only going to use 1/4 cup of butter otherwise the pie is good.

  13. I’ve tried perfecting my mom’s chess pie and it’s never as good as hers but my buttermilk pie turns out great. Love this recipe

  14. White Lily flour is actually different from other brands…. More tender. It is actually made fro. A winter wheat which renders a tender flour. It is better for cakes and biscuits. Other brands are better for breads and dough.

  15. Some other recipes for this pie call for 3 tbsp of lemon juice and a tbsp of lemon zest. It’s no wonder in their reviews that people say it turned out to be a lemon pie instead of buttermilk. I’m gonna stick to the one tbsp of lemon juice to be on the safe side. Every year, our one local grocery store carries lots of fresh pies from Thanksgiving through Christmas. This year for the first time there were none due to Affiliated Foods not sending them to the stores. Huge disappointment for the locals. And the pies were advertised in their weekly sale flyer. We even drove to the next town and the Brookshire’s had no pies either AT CHRISTMAS TIME! Marketing sure is screwed up these days!

      1. I’ve now made three pies from your recipe and they are FANTASTIC! I’ll be needing to go to pie rehab soon! I use one tbsp of vanilla instead of one tsp. Artificial vanilla is what I had on hand and it’s great. This will be my forever recipe. Thanks and happy new year!

        1. try getting some Mexican vanilla! I’ve been using it for more than 20 years and it makes everything better. I buy mine at the Farm patc in Bryan Texas. should be available on Amazon foe deluvery

  16. I’ve had buttermilk pie and LOVE it, this recipe looks almost identical to others I’ve seen except for the lemon juice. I was wondering what the purpose of the lemon juice is?

    1. It balances out the pie its the acid in the lemons it helps to insure your pie not flat tasting like its missing something kinda or brighten it up i put some kinda acid in everything i cook no matter what it may b and at a young age everybody has always been amazed

  17. This is identical to what we in SC know as egg custard. Only difference is buttermilk instead of sweet /evaporated milk & no pie crust.
    I have old receipes for
    ” Makes it own crust ”
    Just butter Pyrex pie dish & pour mixture in & bake at 350° for 30 mins.
    DELISH!!

  18. My people come from Georgia and Kentucky I grew up on things like country gravy biscuits and especially buttermilk pie. One of my daughter’s found this recipe we made it and it was very delicious.

  19. Around my house, buttermilk pies were standard for all major holidays in one form or another. My dad’s favorite was pecan pie, so mother just added pecans and decorated the top with them. For Easter she sometimes made pineapple or chocolate by adding one of those items. I think that my very favorite was absolutely plain, served at room temperature. I’ll compare this to her recipe when I get home, but it looks nearly identical. Thanks! 🙂

  20. any time you see someone, naming a “brand” of product(in this case the flour) disregard the whole thing. they dont give a shit about the recipe, they are just hawking their own product

          1. If you live in the South and have done much baking, You would know there is no flour that equals White Lily. I don’t work for the company and have nothing to gain for what I am saying. Just a country girl who cooks… Just like Mayonnaise … I only use JFG Mayo for any salads I make… It is just sharing our experience and a preference.

    1. I used to think there was no difference until I started doing my own research and testing. Whitelily is my favorite ! It is by far lighter. It is from a different wheat than some of the others thus producing a tender product. It is better for making biscuits, cakes etc. However , other heavier flowers are better for breads in my opinion. I always buy whitelily as my go to flour.

  21. I never heard of butter mike pie until I met a guy from the south,he said his mom use to make it, and I whiched him make it,and now I know how, its very good,I made it for my mom and she loves it, I love to try new things

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *