Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding

Sharing is caring!

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding is so creamy with the perfect texture and sweetness. Only a handful of ingredients and a little patience are needed to make this old time favorite dessert.

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding

 

This Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding tastes just like the KozyShack Rice Pudding I like to buy at the grocery store, only better since it is made from all natural ingredients. This is a stove-top version with just the right amount of sweetness. Only 1/2 cup of sugar is added and most of the sweetness comes from the milk cooking down.

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding is perfectly creamy.

 

It takes a minimum of 50 minutes to get the thickness and texture right. You’ll know it’s done when it’s about the consistency of yogurt. It will thicken up more as it cools, but you stir in a little more milk just before serving to loosen it up some.

No need to go out and buy a bag of short grain or medium grain rice. This Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding cooks prefectly with long grain rice.

Only 5 ingredients needed to make this amazing dessert: milk, sugar, salt, long grain rice, and vanilla extract.

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding- only 5 ingredients!

 

The key to this rice pudding is a very high ratio of milk (a full 6 cups) to rice (just 1/2 cup). You may think when you start that there’s no way it will thicken up enough but it magically does.

This Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding has just the right amount of vanilla fllavor and you can sprinkle some cinnamon on top for extra flavor if you wish or add raisins if that’s your jam.

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding

More Old-Fashioned Desserts

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding is so creamy with the perfect texture and sweetness. Only a handful of ingredients and a little patience are needed to make this old time favorite dessert.
4.66 from 40 votes
Print Pin Rate
Course: Dessert
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 50 minutes
Total Time: 55 minutes
Servings: 4 servings

Ingredients

  • 6 cups whole milk, divided
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1/2 cup long grain white rice, I use a heaping half cup
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • ground cinnamon, optional

Instructions

  • In a large saucepan, combine 5 1/2 cups milk, sugar, and salt. Bring to a boil over medium-high heat.
  • Stir in rice and reduce heat to low. Be sure to adjust the heat so that it is at a gentle simmer.
  • Stirring occasionally, cook for 50 to 60 minutes. Mixture should thicken up to consistency of yogurt.
  • Once thickened, remove from heat and stir in vanilla.
  • Let cool and then refrigerate. The last 1/2 cup milk is stirred in just before serving. Sprinkle with cinnamon if desired.

Recipe Source: Cook’s Country Magazine

Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding #dessert #easyrecipe #rice

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links.

Let's Keep in Touch

Delicious recipes delivered straight to your inbox!



110 thoughts on “Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding

  1. I have about 4 cups steamed white rice leftover from a Chinese order. Can I use this recipe for it, and if so, how much precooked rice should I use?

  2. Recipe was great! I was so skeptical about the ratio of milk to rice, but I was so wrong… absolutely perfect. I halved the recipe (all ingredients), and the end result was so creamy. I initially thought the recipe wasn’t sweet enough for me, so I added some honey, but maybe too much. Next time I’m going to let it cool before I taste and add additional flavor… some patience needed. Thank you for posting this!

  3. Fantastic recipe! I was used almond milk and it came out great. I have made it a few times and varied the recipe a little (added more rice, forgot to add sugar til the end 😂, and added raisins). I found that following the recipe is best except I used 6 cups of almond milk right from the beginning since almond milk has alot of water. I did not cover the pot and stirred every 10-15 min. I actually stirred more often at the end because it started to stick a little. It took about 40-50 min at a steady simmer. When it was almost done I added raisins (about a cup – I love it with raisins) and vanilla. When I eat it, I sprinkle cinnamon on top and sometimes top it with whipped cream. It’s really fantastic!!❤️

  4. Creamy sweet and delicious! Finally a recipe like I remember from childhood! Followed and came out perfect and cooked in less than 50 minutes.

  5. Made this recipe twice. First time, I tried to follow the directions exactly. I learned that time that when the recipe states to be sure the pudding is gently simmering, the heat on your stove needs to be almost halfway up or the pudding will never thicken. I bring the ingredients to a boil between 6 and 7 on my stove (highest setting is 8) and when I reduce the heat, I reduce it to between 3 and 4. If you do that, your pudding will thicken without being covered in under an hour. Anyway, second time, as soon as I removed the finished pudding from the heat, I stirred in one beaten egg. Stir in quickly and a little bit at a time so you don’t have scrambled eggs, then put back on low heat for a couple of minutes to form a sort of custard. Then add vanilla. That change made it very close to my Grandmother’s recipe and makes this 4* recipe a 5 in my opinion. Thanks for the recipe!

  6. Wonderful recipe to build upon. So creamy!
    I’ve always had rice pudding with cinnamon and raisins so I incorporated a teaspoon of cinnamon about half way through simmer and added a cup of rehydrated raisins along with the vanilla. Transported me back!!!

  7. Wonderful recipe to build upon. So creamy!
    I’ve always had rice pudding with cinnamon and raisins so I incorporated a teaspoon of cinnamon about half way through simmer and added a cup of rehydrated raisins along with the vanilla. Transported me back!!!

  8. Yummy. I put a little cinnamon in the milk mixture.. also tempered in a beaten egg yolk.. just felt
    Like doing that. Next time I’ll try without. I’ll add a dash of nutmeg next time. Thanks fir the recipe👍🏽👍🏽

  9. This recipe is a labor of love. You cannot multitask. The commitment is standing one hour by the stove. Make sure the mixture is bubbling like a caldron and stir frequently. The end product is too sweet for my taste so the next time I will be halving the sugar.

  10. 3 hours later and adding 2 cups of milk and 2 cups of water to cut the pudding consistency, rice still not cooked. Maybe 60-70% cooked at this point

    1. 4.5 hours total cook time, added 2 cups of milk and 4 cups of water (on top of 5 1/2 cups milk) to get rice to 90-95% cooked. Severe lack of detail in the instructions. After all the extra work trying to offset the issues in the instructions, had good flavor and consistency, just really hate al dente rice in rice pudding. 🙁

  11. Trick to getting it to recover from “soup” to pudding that nobody’s said yet – and that surprises me – in other words – COVER THE POT! Put a LID on it. THAT’S why the rice won’t expand-it needs the heated steam.

  12. I LOVETHIS RECIPE thank you so much for sharing this is 3rd time I’ve made it and I’m doubling this time it gets ate very fast so for me to be able to get some I’m trying more this time ,its on the stove as im writing this.

  13. Really good! I’ve made a couple of times, and have reduced the sugar to 1/8 cup since I prefer my pudding less sweet. Comes out great.

  14. Amazing! I’m not sure how long I let it simmer, but it did cook down to a yogurt consistency! I was in and out of the kitchen and afraid I would burn it, so I probably had it way too low and compensated by keeping it going for a long time. It worked great all the same. For the people that are calling it soup, this isn’t possible if you let it cook down until it is actually cooked down. You just need to keep cooking it! Follow the recipe (maybe reduce the sugar – I cut it in half and it is still really sweet!) and keep going until you have yogurt consistency. I added raisins when I added the vanilla, and now I’m impatiently waiting for it to cool.

    Thank you for the great directions!

  15. Terrible. I should have known long grain rice wouldnt work. Waste of milk. Also the recipe calls for way too much sugar. Next time itll be pudding rice.

  16. Help …don’t think me stupid, but is the rice cooked or uncooked game you start? I’ve never made this before. My dad is receiving chemo and it’s the one thing he has been eating so I thought I would make it for him. Thanks

  17. My fiance and I buy Kozy Shack rice pudding from the store. He always grabs the the little snack cup 6 packs. When we get home he eats 4 or 5 of them right away. Lol. So I was hoping I could find a recipe that tastes as good and I could make in a large batch for less money. Well, I just made this recipe and I must say this exceeded my expectations. The flavor brings you right to something that came out of Grandma’s kitchen when you were a child. And by far blows the store bought rice pudding out of the water. It’s a simple easy recipe and I can tell you I will Never buy rice pudding from a store again.

  18. I love this recipe. It is easy to make and only uses milk, not cream. Great yummy way to use up milk before it sours! I make it with 2% milk.

  19. followed this recipe to a T. it was perfect. you cant mess this recipe up. top/no top, doesnt matter. I didnt use a top, simmered 50 minutes, added just over a heaping 1/2 cup rice, tadah!!! people, just follow the directions, use common sense, who cares how big a serving is, who really measures anyway. Quit nitpicking. Just cook and enjoy. Delicious.

  20. Creamy, just enough sweet and so delicious! I’ve made other rice pudding recipes in the past and failed. I decided to give it one more go and this one came out perfect! My house smells so yummy right now. Only change I made was 6 cups of milk to start and added 1 cup of rice to double servings. I kept the same amount of sugar, salt and vanilla, then sprinkled some cinnamon on top before placing in the fridge to cool. Can’t wait to taste it chilled! Simplest and most tastiest recipe by far. Thank you for sharing! I’ll be making this one again and again.

  21. I always believed in when BAKING or COOKING anything when it Comes to the SALT even if YOU try to MAKE a Double batch, never to use More than a PINCH of SALT. And apologies for SPOILING THE Recipe. The best way to make it more creamy (even when i make my SAUCES) I NEVER go wrong by using a bit of BAKING STORK only a Table spoon full.

  22. Should this be covered to simmer like regular rice? The recipe doesn’t specify but it seems to form a skin when uncovered. Tyia

  23. It was one of the easiest rice pudding recipes I have ever made!! I will not use the 1/2 cup of sugar next time, but a wee bit less.. thanks for making it so easy

    1. If you have an electric stove, you HAVE to Summer with a top on .. I hate electric stoves! It did come out perfect though after almost exactly 50 minutes! I would use a little less sugar though….very sweet! Thanks for the recipe!

  24. Very easy and really very good. However what do you consider a serving?? You give calculations on a serving bit don’t specify what it is , cup, half cup, quarter cup, pint????

  25. I’m trying to figure out the difference between your 6-cups of milk and a heaping 1/2-cup or long rain rice. I use the same rice that I cook for our dogs which is, 4-cups of water and 2-cups of rice. I add the rice to the boiling water, stir, turn down to simmer, and cover for 15-120 minutes. I remove from the hot burner to a cool one and let it sit cover for a while. It comes out perfect. I just don’t understand the 6-cups of milk to a heaping 1/2-cup of long grain rice. Mine has been on a low fire for 50 minutes and it’s not done.

  26. I’m surprised there’s no lid added to the pot. I stir occasionally, I’ve got 21-minutes left and it does seem like there’s any change in the consistency. And, there is skimming on the top of the mixture.

  27. Hello Christin
    I’m so glad you shared your recipe I just made it and I used almond milk and I followed the recipe to a T and the recipe turned out perfect I’m impressed I’ll definitely be making it again delicious thank you blessings

  28. AT LAST I FOUND A RECIPE THAT IS DIABETIC AND LACTOSE INTOLERANT FREE… I USED LACTOSE FREE MILK AND OLLOWED THE RECIPE… DELICIOUS AND GUILD FREE (FOR ME)

  29. My husband and I have been eating Kozy Shack rice pudding like crazy lately. Can I use minute rice and either 2% or heavy whipping cream? I have been looking for a recipe that suits him…he likes kozy shack because “it tastes just like Mom’s”.

  30. I am attempting to make this rice pudding last recipe yuk! I am hoping for a great yummy turnout🥰my family is craving this dish!

  31. I make rice putting all the time. Send someone else to the store and a boy uncle Ben’s parboiled long grain rice wondering if this is OK to use

    1. Use less milk and match to rice amount. For example if the recipe calls for 1,5 cups of rice and 6 cups of milk, you should be able to get by with only 2-3 cups of milk. Start by adding 2 cups of milk to the previously cooked rice and stir in more as needed.

  32. Absolutely amazing!! I have made some nasty rice pudding before by following different recipes, this was not like those at all. I’ve made it three times since finding the recipe a week ago.

  33. Thank you for this recipe! I lost a recipe years ago and had been buying rice pudding at the grocery store ever since. The pudding came out delicious, just like my Mother used to make!

  34. Best rice pudding we have had in years, thanks to everyone who has written a review as we added, less sugar due to family member’s being diabetic, added sultanas , vanilla and only a small amount of the salt to help cut the sweetness. It turned out wonderful, so creamy, I have to be honest and admit that I had my doubts with the amount of milk to rice, but so glad I read the reviews.
    Once again thank you Christin and everyone. I have been sending the web page to all of my friends for them to try it 😉

  35. After getting the milk to boil and adding the rice I put it on low simmer. Took 90 minutes went nowhere. Had to increase the temperature on the electric stove to slightly less than medium heat.It finally thickened up but how is it possible to cook rice in a low simmer. Just didn’t work for me

    1. On an electric stove when a recipe calls for you to lower the heat I turn on another burner to a low temp and transfer the pot to that burner this way it isn’t still cooking at the higher temp hope that this helps some

    1. I also had to simmer mine 90 minutes. Not sure if I care for all the vanilla. It would s good but not sure it’s worth all the time I put into it

  36. Just made this to take to a church potluck. It is so thick! I had to put together what milk I had so ended up using 6 cups whole milk, 2 cups heavy cream, and 3 cups 1% for a double batch. I have to stop and pick up some whole milk to add the 1 cup before serving. I also forgot to add the vanilla since I had to rush off to an appointment so I guess I’ll add that with the additional milk. It’s pretty tasty even without it, and oh so creamy.

  37. I used almond milk and the consistency was perfect.
    However I also used the exact amount of salt the recipe calls for and 1/3 cup of sugar and it turned out waaaaay too salty, it’s pretty much ruined. No salt next time will be perfect.
    Curious if anyone turned out with a salty pudding using regular milk and less sugar? So strange.

    1. Basically all salts have a different taste. You should taste how salty yours is before adding what a recipe calls for. A sprinkle of yours might be perfect, while a 1/2 teaspoon of hers would be correct.

  38. I cooked this for my triplet rats and they all got dead. I tried the rice and it tasted absolutely scrumptious. This recipe is the most superb. BUT I do NOT condone feeding it to your rats because they will most certainly DIE. and don’t think that you will be able to revive them using a psychic book because it won’t work because trust me I’ve tried. OH and NEVER EVER NEVER dip knock off Doritos in this rice pudding because you will most definitely puke it up (i know i did). Also, i don’t suggest giving this to your neighborhood sewer cat as its meal because the next day I found it dead, under my car. (I’m not sure if it was sleeping or not but whatever). K BYE LOVE YA LOTS!!!!

  39. I used 2% milk, as I had a gallon needing to be used..I put half cup heavy cream to make up the fat..turned out perfect! I put in half cup raisins half way through cook time. When I put the vanilla in, I also put a quick shake of ground cinnamon and ground nutmeg..it is very nice. This is a great recipe..thank you! Enjoyed making this!

    1. I liked the pudding because it used long grain rice. I doubled the recipe for a party. It took 2 hours from adding the rice to get to the right consistency. It needed more vanilla. Do you think using basmati rice caused it to require 2 hours of cooking?

  40. Found this recipe yesterday and an hour later was making it. AMAZING !! Easiest recipe in my 60ish years of cooking and baking. I made it exactly as written, but, I see so many options to add/customize this rice pudding.
    I’ve been searching for a rice pudding that,would be somewhat close to my mother’s and have found it.
    Thank you for adding this recipe to my file.

  41. The best rice pudding! So thick and creamy, not overly sweet. Patience is key to this recipe however, don’t rush it and you will never buy premise again. Xx

    1. My rice pudding is cooking as we speak, followed recipe and instead of cooking on stove top i am baking in a low oven
      Looking at everyones comments about the salt has me worried though. Maybe i should have skipped the salt, we shall see though ‘the proof is in the pudding ‘

  42. OMG!!!!!! This is the best and easiest recipe for rice pudding!!! I have never made it before because I dont care for it. Well my 13yr old son is a huge fan of it. He had been begging me to try and make it for him. So I decided to give it a go. Oh am I ever glad I did!!! It is so good!! (Remember when I said I didn’t care for it.) I don’t know how i have gone this long without it!!! Thank you so so much for sharing with us!!! You made my sons night!!!!😊

  43. I made 1/2 of the recipe and used 2 percent goats milk at the end I added 1/2 beaten egg with the vanilla and a bit of milk. Really creamy, delicious!

      1. Christin,
        my husband is diabetic also, and I just made snother Rice Pudding with Splenda, brown rice and cashew milk, but used 2 c. Milk, 2 c. Brown rice, 2 eggs, vanilla, rum, raisins, bit butter, Nutmeg/Cinnamon, 1/2 pinch sea salt. I cooked for 15-20 min. Then added raisins and beaten eggs. I cooked 2 min. , stirring constantly, then removed from heat and added butter and flavorings, mixed well. I went an extra step and beat the eggshites with 1/4 tdp. Cream of tarter and teo splenda, which I gently folded in, after pudding cooled to luke warm. Yields 2 large servings or more with smaller servings.
        Enjoy,

  44. Hi..I’m wondering if anyone (Christin)knows the calorie count for this awesome sounding rice pudding ? Thanks,Jim and Tawnya

    1. Fantastic as written! My Italian aunt use to make us this same concoction of ingredients, but she’s not one to measure. So happy to have found this recipe to guide me. Those folks cutting sugar, salt, etc., I’d kindly suggest cutting sugar and salt elsewhere, as this isn’t a high sugar or salt recipe, and it’s also an indulgence! Artificial sugars are worse than you can imagine, spiking insulin higher than white sugar.

  45. Excellent recipe and instructions – particularly the guidance to wait for the pudding to reduce until it achieves the consistency of yogurt . My previous efforts at rice pudding always resulted in something which, while pleasant, didn’t have the creaminess this recipe has. The salt was also new to me, and made a world of difference, adding a depth and richness that balances the sweetness perfectly. Many people would prefer half the quantity, but for me it was perfect.
    You didn’t say to cover the pan while cooking, but I did because I have always done so in the past. That resulted in a wet pudding after 50 minutes, so I had to uncover it, turn up the gas a little to maintain the simmer, and cook for a full 30 minutes longer. This resulted in the breakdown of a lot more rice grains than would have occurred in only 50 minutes, but many people might actually like the thicker, bulkier sauce. I’ll try it uncovered next time.
    My bottom line: the flavor and texture of this recipe are so good that I would never consider adding anything else to it to serve, other than a dash of milk to thin it slightly.

    1. Addendum:
      I tried cooking without covering for the first forty minutes or so. While the reduction progressed as desired, the heat necessary to maintain a gentle simmer was so great that with my gas stove I had caramelization and browning in patches on the bottom of the pan. Thought it makes the flavor more complex, stirred-in the brown bits look unsightly in my opinion. I use a Circulon pan which, by nature of the circular indentations in the bottom, has greater surface area which helps reduce burning, but even that didn’t solve the heat distribution problem. The problem with gas is that at the lower settings the flame may or may not touch the bottom of the pan, so the heat transfer can vary significantly with very little adjustment. Maybe you electric or ceramic folk don’t have this problem.
      For the completion of cooking, I elected to partially cover the pan – the effect one would get by leaving a spoon in the pan with the lid on. That reduced the heat loss enough that I could adjust the flame as to not touch the bottom of the pan yet still maintain a gentle simmer and also achieve the desired reduction. The time to cook with this combined uncovered/covered technique was 65 minutes. The pudding was not as thick as in the first attempt, but was more suitable for consuming cold.
      Next time – and that won’t be long as I absolutely love this rice pudding – I’ll partially cover from the start. I’ll report back here for those who, like me, have the obsessive need to perfect everything 🙂

  46. I had a lot of 1% milk to use up. I loved that this recipe used 6 cups. It turned out delicious using the 1%. Can only imagine what whole milk would be like. So easy.
    No eggs to temper.Yey. Oh and I added 1/2 cup of raisins when I added the rice. I have to admit it boiled over once and got away from me. What a mess! All in all a great recipe. Thank you.

  47. I have never been able to make rice pudding. It never turns out. I know now why. I used too much rice. When I try this recipe I will post a pic.

        1. I was wondering the same thing. I cannot have dairy milk, and I am wondering if soy or almond milk would work. I think I’m going to try it with vanilla soy and see how it goes.

          1. I used almond milk and it came out great. It looks like it will turn out watery half way through but keep cooking at a low simmer and it all thickens up nicely in the end. I don’t recommend adding the salt at all.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *