Southern Spaghetti Sauce

Southern Spaghetti Sauce

This spaghetti sauce is one of my favorite comfort foods to make and it reminds me of the sauce my grandmother used to make. It was always a treat when we got it because my grandmother only knew how to cook two things that I’m aware of- spaghetti sauce and shrimp salad. It’s very thick andย full of ground beef, onions, and bell peppers. A hefty spoonful of sugar adds some sweetness and cuts any bitterness in the tomatoes. Two whole cans of tomato paste give it an extra intense flavor.

Sothern Spaghetti Sauce

I like this sauce so much, I have been known to skip the pasta and just eat a bowl full of sauce with a spoon. With lots of Parmesan cheese on top- the kind in the green can. Usually I prefer fresh Parmesan on things, but maybe since I grew up eating spaghetti sauce like this one with grated Parmesan out of a can, it’s just what I crave.

Childhood food memories are the best aren’t they?

This sauce freezes really well and I’ll often make a double batch of it and freeze half for a second meal.

Southern Spaghetti Sauce

4.88 from 8 votes
Southern Spaghetti Sauce
Southern Spaghetti Sauce
Thick and meaty spaghetti sauce flavored with onions, green peppers, and a little sweetness.
Course: Italian
  • 1 1/2 pounds lean ground beef
  • 1 large onion, diced
  • 1 green bell pepper, diced
  • 1 clove garlic, minced
  • 2 (6-ounce) cans tomato paste
  • 1 (8-ounce) can tomato sauce
  • 1 (14 1/2-ounce) can stewed tomatoes
  • 1 tablespoon Italian Seasoning
  • 1 tablespoon Worcestershire Sauce
  • 1 tablespoon sugar, the original recipe calls for 2 tablespoons, but I just add one
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1 cup water
  1. Brown beef in a large heavy bottomed pot. Drain fat.
  2. Add onion and green pepper and saute until onion is tender, about 5 minutes. Add garlic and saute 30 seconds.
  3. Add tomato paste, tomato sauce, stewed tomatoes, seasonings, and water.
  4. Simmer 3o minutes.
Recipe Notes

Note: If you're nervous about the amount of sugar, start with 1/2 tablespoon and add more if desired.

Recipe Source: adapted from Paula Deen

For More Southern Recipes FOLLOW my Southern Foods Board on Pinterest

Follow Spicy Southern Kitchen| Christin Mahrlig’s board Southern Foods on Pinterest.

62 thoughts on “Southern Spaghetti Sauce

  1. This recipe needs a little more clarity in that there is no mention of when to add the Worcestershire sauce and if the juice from the stewed tomatoes is incorporated in the recipe or drained.

    That being said, I have this simmering on the stove as I type. Have been looking for a recipe that I thought would come close to the spaghetti I had at an Oklahoma dinner, many decades ago. The list of ingredients sounded right, but found the taste a little lacking in the cooking process. Added a few more spices and am letting simmer longer, so the flavors are enhanced. I will try this recipe again and kick it up as I go along. Thanks for posting!

  2. Just wanted to know, what makes this Southern? It’s a general pasta sauce recipe that has been around for years and is used throughout North America(Canada & USA). How do I know? My grandmothers made sauce that way and there’s nothing Southern in us. So, just because it’s adapted from Paula Dean, that makes a general sauce recipe Southern? Just sayin’

      1. I have always put sugar in mine and I’m a northern girl. Born in Green Bay Wisconsin lived in Fairbank Alaska and Washington state and now living in Eau Claire Wisconsin.

        1. It’s okay for someone in the south to post their Fav dish with the word Southern in it. I’m sure you’re not claiming the invention of the sauce. Don’t stress, everyone is a critic on the Internet. I think this dish looks/sounds AMAZING and I don’t care which region it’s from. ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Christin: Old post and normally I do not post or reply to posts (I will rate the article after I try it, but that’s about it), but I canNOT restrain myself from commenting! HOW is a random visitor to YOUR blog going to have the gall / nerve to judge and criticize your blog post? Look woman (Olivia), if YOU do not like the recipe or disagree with anything here, MOVE ON to the next dang blog! There’s only a zillion out there in cyberspace! The blog host clearly has very fond and precious memories of her grandmother and her grandmother’s recipe for spaghetti; Her grandmother was from the SOUTH and served an amazing spaghetti dish with LOVE, so add the two and THAT makes this recipe SOUTHERN! (people these days … O.o ) Now, onto important questions and comments: is this served best with thin or regular spaghetti noodles – or some other kind of pasta? I mean, when you eat it with pasta …LOL! I can totally see myself eating it straight (no noodles). Sounds like a lovely dish and I have sent my hubs a message to pick up what I need to make it this afternoon. I am going to use some canned tomatoes that we made at home, though: Nothing in the world like Slocomb, Alabama tomatoes, y’all (and, that would also make this recipe SOUTHERN!) I’ll let you know how mine turns out, though.

      1. Phyllis, you took the words right out of my mouth!! So being a Southern girl , born in Ky (only there long enough to be born) and whoโ€™s Mom, Grandma and Great Grandma were born and raised in a town called Hoo Doo Tn (just down the road from Manchester Tn) I grew up in Tn but from age 10 till today have lived in Ga so my southern roots run deep. All Iโ€™m going to add (while shaking my head) to all whoโ€™ve complained about it being called โ€œSouthern Spaghetti Sauceโ€ is โ€œBless their heartsโ€. I think us Southerners add the word because weโ€™re proud of our Southern Heritage!! Itโ€™s a great recipe. Iโ€™ve made it as written and Iโ€™ve doctored it up to suit me, which I seem to have to do to all recipes…lol. But sugar is my secret ingredient to several soups, sauces, goulash, peas etc.
        Christin, thanks for the great recipes!!

  3. Your receipe is almost exactly like my except the sugar and Worcestershire sauce. I’m kinds afraid to try the two because my may not like it

  4. Your recipe is much like my own. One thing that I do different is using Chicken Broth instead of water, and a dry red wine. You may have to simmer a bit longer to get it as thick as yours. Carrots are also a good addition.

  5. While reading through this recipe, I was forced to listen to an ad for Mucinex (? sp) and totally lost my appetite. I understand that blogs depend on ads but listening to someone go on about a phlemmy cough while I am looking for what to fix for supper is way too much!! YUCK.

  6. This was delish!! I made the recipe exactly how it read and once the meat was done cooking with the veggies, I threw the meat and the rest of the ingredients in the crock pot. Cooked on low for 3 hours. Super yummy!!

    1. Thank you for posting how long in the crockpot. I’m making meatballs in the oven and will throw them in around the 2 hour mark, started it off on high but will bring it down to low. Thought about putting a tsp of red pepper in it.

  7. I always toss in some diced celery and mushrooms. MMMMMM.

    It’s cold in Delaware and this looks like my dinner for tonight! ๐Ÿ™‚


  8. I make a sauce very similar to this that was given to me by my Mom. The only major differences are that I always add Italian sausage and I usually let it simmer all day either in a crock pot or simmer on the stovetop, if I know I will be home all day! Great spaghetti sauce!!

  9. Hi Christin

    I made this for the 4th July and everybody loved it, they liked how thick it is and the flavor was spot on. I didn’t know whether to simmer the ground beef with the sauce, so I just threw it in there with the sauce. Thanks for sharing, I will be making this recipe over and over again.

  10. This sauce looks AMAZING! I’m totally with you on eating the sauce without the pasta- that’s the best part of a chunky sauce ๐Ÿ™‚ I wish my hubby liked ground beef. I might just have to make it and eat it all myself…

  11. I just made a huge batch of spaghetti sauce after new years as there’s nothing better after ham, turkey, beef, etc. Your sauce sounds so good with all of that tomato paste and the green peppers. Looks delicious!

  12. Wow this looks so thick and chunky and awesome! Childhood food memories are the best – I have a few things that I just won’t change even though I usually prefer other things etc… just because of the sentimental value they somehow taste better! Hope you’re having a great weekend!

  13. This chunky sauce looks incredible Christin, I would totally eat a bowl full of this sauce alone too. It sounds so flavorful and tasty and I love that it reminds you of your grandmother’s version ๐Ÿ™‚

  14. Oh boy – this chunky, meaty sauce is calling out to me! I can see why you’d be satisfied with just the sauce itself! And how nice that it reminds you of your grandmother (even if she could only cook 2 things ; ).

  15. I love how chunky this sauce is. I can see why you eat it straight without the pasta. It’s so hearty and yummy, I’d do the same thing! Pinned. Happy New Year Christin! Looking forward to see more of your delicious recipes. ๐Ÿ™‚

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *